Just want to see if you guys/girls think my sig is very good or not. Just looking for some helpful criticism. let me know good or bad. Thanks
also, let me know which you think is better if you don't mind, black and white or black and red.
Thanks
perfict

Not bad for a first try !

yea it s pretty good

Thanks alot, i'll put up another when it's done

Yea thats awesome, I like the black and white

It good for a first try

thanks for the replies, please feel free to tell me what i could do to improve.. or not if you don't want to
Thanks any
perfict

Pretty nice 4 been a newbie!
U can download some brushes in deviantart.com
Try to brush ur sigs, thats would make u sigs looks nicer

And please dont make ur sigs to large!

Can u make the sig ur using smaller?

Thanks for the info,(not sure what you mean brush my sigs, I used flame, and grunge script brushes) you mean like over the pics maybe?? Let me know I want to get better. Oh and is this size a little better?
Thanks
perfict

Not bad for a first cept all the white blotches around...they just look too random.If you wanna add texture like that,keep it in the background,and the pictures and text on the top layers.

Nice try but the der r too many black box so if u decrease a little bit of black stuff den it will look nice, I think!!!!!!

not bad for a first try you will get awesome with some more practice. i wish i had that kinda potential.

What i mean with brushing is that u brush like ur BG(background)
example: http://i33.photobucket.com/albums/d69/narutobt/IRONMAN.jpg
[Only Photoshop 7 or up^, maybe some old ones too]

Then u can fix some colors in ur brushed BG using the "grandient overlay" or "Color balance"
Layer -> Layer style -> Grandiet overlay
Ctrl + B = Color balance
Ctrl + U = Hue/Saturation

very good for a first try i see that in the future u will become a pro

pic and background doesnt go well, try to reinforce the egges on you're pics and try to get rid of the blue around some of you're stock

i agree. also, have something in the foreground, too much is alpha'd.

however, i'm PS illiterate, so good work, and work with styles.

the picture is a little blur...

i believe that it's pretty good for a first try! keep working hard, i know you're going to get better!

uh not bad for your first try i did it one my fisrt try and it showed only part of the picture that i cuted out.

its cool